Anonymity in 360-degree feedback

Should 360-degree feedback be anonymous? There is no simple answer to this question, because it all depends on the objectives of a particular feedback project in a particular organisation and on the relationships involved: who is assessing whom.

Relationships: assessment from different perspectives

Most often, 360-degree feedback uses the conventional relationships: manager, colleagues, direct reports and clients. These relationships are not equivalent. Feedback from a manager, whose responsibilities include regularly assessing their direct reports, is different from feedback from a colleague or direct report, who assess from an entirely different position. Direct reports in particular, when asked to assess their immediate manager’s behaviour and competencies, have every right to feel somewhat uncertain in this role. They may well fear that expressing their honest opinions, especially less favourable ones, could negatively affect their relationship with their manager and even their continued employment. It is therefore important to ensure that employees providing feedback feel comfortable, because only then can we be confident that their responses are honest.

What does anonymity of responses in 360-degree feedback involve?

The results of 360-degree feedback are presented in individual and group reports. The person being assessed receives a summary of the ratings given by representatives of each relationship group for a particular competency (or a particular behavioural indicator). Individual ratings are generally provided alongside the average, because their spread conveys a great deal of valuable information. A situation in which all direct reports rate their manager as 3 differs from one in which half give a rating of 5 and half a rating of 1, although the average is the same in both cases. Individual ratings are, of course, not assigned to named individuals. But what happens when an employee group contains just 1 or 2 people? Matching a rating to an employee is then very easy, so there can be no question of anonymity. In such cases, a very common approach is to reduce the possibility of identifying individual employees by combining such a small group with employees from another relationship group. This preserves anonymity, and employees need not worry that their opinions will affect their future work with their manager.

our clients most often choose

  • ACE

    The ACE potential test assesses the ability to reason logically and analytically and to learn. It supports recruitment and the assessment of employees’ development potential, helping to plan career paths in line with their capabilities.

    more
  • 360-degree

    Employees differ in their character traits, competencies and potential. Knowing their strengths and weaknesses makes it possible to plan development activities. Through 360-degree feedback participants will find out how…

    more
  • AC

    An objective, multidimensional staff selection technique, Assessment Centre is a tool that enables you to recruit people with the right competencies and potential. It has remained popular worldwide for years because….

    more
  • DC

    To gain reliable knowledge of employees’ skills and potential, it is worth using Development Centre, a comprehensive competency assessment process. It allows you to discover the potential within employees and what to do to…

    more