Who should decide who assesses whom in 360-degree feedback?
When preparing 360-degree feedback in an organisation, it is essential to create a matrix showing who will assess whom. Feedback providers should primarily be people who know the person being assessed well, ideally because they work together every day. It is also important to include not only those who work well with the person being assessed, but also people whose relationships with them are less positive. The group providing feedback should be as representative as possible. So who should be responsible for creating the best possible matrix?
- The HR department
The HR department seems ideal for this type of task. But is it really? On the one hand, it knows the structure of the whole organisation, responsibilities and reporting relationships extremely well. On the other, it does not work with everyone every day and, particularly in larger and geographically dispersed organisations, is not always familiar with the specific relationships between individuals. Selecting someone who rarely interacts with the person being assessed will not produce valuable feedback. Nevertheless, it is undoubtedly the HR department that should coordinate development of the matrix and oversee the entire process within the organisation.
- The CEO / management board
This approach could work only in a small company where everyone knows each other personally very well. The CEO or management board could, at most, identify individual relationships between employees in roles that are key to the company.
- The person being assessed
This is generally a good approach, although there is a risk that some people being assessed may wish to invite only those they are certain will give them positive ratings. It is therefore worth introducing arrangements to check that people with somewhat more critical views are not being omitted from the matrix. Having the person’s immediate manager approve the group providing feedback may be a good idea.
- The feedback providers
In theory, employees could be asked to volunteer and identify the people they would like to assess. However, leaving this decision to feedback providers could result in a range of undesirable or simply pointless behaviours, such as “I like Krysia personally, so I’ll volunteer to assess her even though I don’t work with her every day”, or “Jacek really upset me once, so now I have a chance to get my own back”.
- An external company
Even the best external company does not know the organisation as well as its employees do, so it should not be responsible for selecting feedback providers. Its role is primarily to oversee the feedback process, provide specialist and methodological support, and prepare reliable reports that guarantee everyone anonymity and data confidentiality.